Tai Chi and Cardiovascular Health
There is evidence, though sometimes controversial,
that exercise improves many aspects of cardiovascular health including
reduced incidence of coronary heart disease, stroke, and hypertension.
[1],
[2],
[3]
The majority of this research has focused on the impact of vigorous
or moderate exercise. Less is known about the cardiovascular benefits
of lower intensity exercise, such as Tai
Chi.
A growing body of evidence suggests Tai Chi practice, even over
short periods of time, may improve cardiovascular health. Depending
on how it is practiced, Tai Chi has been characterized as a low
to moderate intensity exercise. Three studies are briefly discussed
to illustrate the types of evidence available to evaluate the
impact that Tai Chi may have on components of cardiovascular health.
Young et al. [4]
conducted a well designed, randomized controlled trial with 62
subjects that compared the effects of aerobic exercise versus
Tai Chi on blood pressure in mildly hypertensive older adults.
Over the 12-week study period, Tai Chi was observed to be equally
effective as aerobic exercise in reducing both systolic and diastolic
blood pressure. Lai et al. [5]
conducted a longitudinal, prospective study comparing two-year
trends in cardiorespiratory function of a group of elderly Tai
Chi practitioners (n=45) with an age-matched, sedentary control
group (n=39). Their results suggest that Tai Chi may delay the
decrease in aerobic capacity usually found with aging. Lan et.
al. [6]
conducted a cross-sectional, case-controlled study to evaluate
the health benefits of long-term, geriatric Tai Chi practitioners.
Cycle ergometry revealed that peak oxygen uptake was greater for
Tai Chi practitioners (n=41) compared to age-matched sedentary
subjects (n=35). No adverse effects related to the short- or long-term
practice of Tai Chi were reported in any of these studies. These
and other studies are summarized in reviews by Li et al. [7]
and Lan et al. [8].
In summary, these and related studies suggest that Tai Chi is
a safe exercise, even for frail elders, and may be beneficial
to various aspects of cardiovascular health. It requires no specialized
equipment, is relatively inexpensive and can be taught/learned
in a group setting. Tai Chi appears to elicit a cardiovascular
response equivalent to that associated with moderate intensity
exercise, and as such meets the American College of Sports Medicine,
American Heart Association, and Centers for Disease Control recommendations
for daily performance of low- to moderate-intensity activities
[9].
However, studies have yet to investigate whether the physiological
mechanisms by which Tai Chi impacts cardiovascular health are
the same as those believed to relate to more typical endurance
and aerobic training [10].
